Unsolved Mysteries Wiki
Unsolved Mysteries Wiki

Real Names: Ann Sigmin and Garey Edward Goff
Aliases: Andy Hayes, Andy Partlowe (Ann); Wiley (Garey)
Wanted For: Murder
Missing Since: October 26, 1986


Details: Ann Sigmin is the wife of thirty-nine-year-old Charles "Charlie" Sigmin; he was known as a God-fearing man who had a reputation for hard work and getting along well with others. However, his personal life did not go as well as his professional one, being checkered with failed relationships and periods of loneliness. When he married Ann, he felt he had a stable relationship. Shortly after, he sold his home and used the money to acquire a nine-acre truck farm; they named it "C & A's" after their initials. Charlie also took in Ann's two sons from a previous marriage, accepting them like his own and having them live with him on his farm.
During summer 1986, Charlie began to suspect that Ann was seeing another man. Trouble continued when she developed a strange attraction and curiosity with demonic worship and witchcraft. It was first noticed once in the dead of night when Charlie saw a strange glow coming from his tool shed and investigated. He walked in to see Ann in her underwear kneeling before an image of a demon, chanting and mesmerized with a semicircle of candles around her. He interrupted her trance. He became concerned for his marriage and what kind of woman he married, especially when he found satanic literature among her possessions. He also remembered that three weeks earlier, he had found a doll on his bed; she told him that she had used it for witchcraft rituals.

Charlie Sigmin

Feeling he had not known Ann that well before marrying her, Charlie served her divorce papers, and she and her sons moved to Caruthersville, Missouri. She began dating a truck driver and retired cop named Garey Goff, with whom she soon cohabited. Interestingly, despite the geographic distance, Charlie knew him from his childhood, both having attended the same elementary school. Charlie soon became depressed and resumed contact with Ann, but his depression and separation ended after Garey made a series of threatening phone calls to him. Although he regained his senses and forgot about Ann, he surprisingly made no effort to stop Garey, whose activities, which could have been viewed as harassment or intimidation, were not reported to the local police.
On the night of October 19, 1986, Charlie received a phone call from Ann. She said she was suicidal and that her sons were very upset. He was with a friend at the time and told her he thought this plea was inauthentic, but that he would go anyway. According to his friend, he was sober; although he was thinking about bringing his pistol with him, he decided to leave it behind. At around 3am on October 20, he arrived at Garey's house, and about twenty minutes later he was dead. Ann quickly went to the nearby police station and told them that he had been shot.
When authorities investigated the scene, the blood on the walls and floor pointed to evidence of a struggle. Charlie had been shot seven times; twice in the leg, once in the groin, once in the jaw, once in the right hand, once in the right ear, and once in the neck. The latter was the fatal shot. Two guns were found: a .32 revolver was lying on the floor; and a .25 caliber pistol was on top of the TV. Both had been fired. In addition, a bloody steam iron was found in the wastebasket in the kitchen.
When questioned, Ann and Garey said that Charlie had come to the house and demanded to be let in. When they refused, he forced his way and, in a drunken rage, began to beat Ann. Garey then hit him with an iron and shot him several times in self-defense. He claimed that he had fired all seven shots, but Ann admitted that she had handled the .25 caliber pistol.
Authorities were hesitant to believe their story, especially when Charlie's friend was interrogated by the police and she said he had not been drinking with her, nor had he been known to be a heavy drinker. Authorities believed that if both she and Garey had fired at him, there would be grounds for a premeditated murder charge. A powder residue test to determine if Ann fired a gun was inconclusive. Authorities also failed to take a blood sample from Charlie's body to check blood alcohol content to determine the validity of the drunkenness claim. Ann and Garey were released without being charged, but the police had not concluded their investigation of Charlie's death and still had reason to believe both were suspects.
A friend of Ann's soon came forward and said that she had reasons for wanting Charlie dead. A few days after his murder, her friend was given a wire and she made incriminating statements suggesting that she and Garey were going to leave town. Her friend told her that she was going to talk to the police, but Ann told her to wait until she and Garey had left town.
After the recorded conversation, authorities began to prepare an arrest warrant for Ann and Garey. However, they both vanished; she left her sons behind, and his truck was later found abandoned in Phoenix, Arizona. Authorities are still divided on whether or not Charlie's death was self-defense or murder. The only way this case can be resolved is when Ann and Garey have their day in court. They have never been officially served with a warrant and may have no idea that they are wanted by the police.
Extra Notes: This case first aired on the November 30, 1988 episode.
Fearing publicity, Charlie's friend (who was with him the night before his murder) remained anonymous, being interviewed in silhouette and revealing that his and Ann's marriage was not as perfect as most would believe, seeing as he beat her periodically.
Interestingly, unlike most Wanted segments, there was doubt over whether or not Ann and Garey were guilty; evidence was presented supporting both self-defense and murder.

Composites of how Ann may look today

Results: Unresolved. Garey had seen the broadcast and surrendered himself to authorities in May 1989. He told the police that he broke up with Ann shortly before the broadcast, and that she threatened to put satanic curses on him should he cooperate with them. However, a combination of a guilty conscience and fear of his exposure on the broadcast were a stronger motivator for him to surrender. In January 1991, he entered an Alford Plea for second-degree murder. He was sentenced to twenty years in prison and was paroled in 2002.
Ann has yet to be apprehended. While in prison, Garey publicly begged her to turn herself into the authorities, but she never did. She has been a fugitive for more than thirty years and would be in her 50s today. She is believed to be living in either Arizona or Oregon. She is also believed to be taking advantage of her physical features to falsely identify herself as an American Indian and feign acculturation with Indian nations. As such, tribal police have also been alerted that she may be a danger to their areas. As of 2020, she was rumored to be living in Tennessee or an Indian reservation out west.